On Queers and Unicorns

“Are unicorns gay?” is a question I’ve been wondering about ever since I was a teen about a decade ago. Funnily enough, unicorns seem to be more Christian than anything to me growing up, and the same thought came up recently as the curator of the Met Cloisters revisited “The Unicorn Tapestries” originally from France and the Netherlands.

My queries in NYPL’s books and research databases confirmed unicorns’ ties with both Medieval art and Fantasy literature. Some top MARC records (including “The Lady and the unicorn,” “A swiftly tilting planet,” and “the last unicorn”) have Fantasy fiction, magic/magicians or something similar as subjects. But it is also a delight to see children’s and young adult titles published in the recent decade include subject terms such as such as identity and friendship (see “Not quite narwhal,” “A good team,” and “Party hearty kitty corn”). These descriptions kind of resonate with the 2010s discourse I’ve been part of.

Bibliographic Information from NYPL’s Catalog

Another part of me feels that my initial question can be traced somewhere earlier in history. So I went on Gale to retrieve more information from a specialized database called Archives of Sexuality and Gender. I discovered that unicorns have been a symbol of gay (LGBTQ+) activism as early as the 1970s. With OCR, I found more direct citations from articles and ephemera. Things as recent as a flyer from the 2012 Vancouver Genderfest or as remote as an article by Denise McConnell titled “Unicorns exist for free spirits” on an Oklahoma-based feminist newspaper that came out back in 1978. Amid all matches based on keyword search, there is a common theme: people being drawn to a mythical narrative and therefore owning it. I cite Glad Day Bookstore’s manager Scott Dagostino for a lack of better words. “It’s not like anyone made an official decision about this, yet somehow it seems to have become an universal truth.” Unicorns as imagery exactly rest in the interstices of knowledge organization, where “imaginative powers” prevail.

Samples of the Keyword Preview Feature on Gale

The rupture between symbols and subject headings has been going on and reinforced with classification, a field demanding enumerable accuracy rather than a regional/cultural take. I guess Foucault wouldn’t lament the lack of liberty in such an organization since it was the start of a more fluid and modern way to look at knowledge production. Our contemporary era definitely has brought us more to unsettle as I browsed the above data and noticed how “faceted” archival resources can be on a computer. From literature/genre fiction to art history and LGBTQ+ icons, you always have a node to work from and a chain of connections where you can expand. This testifies to the addition of “facets” in classification, with which catalogers can play with hierarchies and add new subdivisions… Facets are also a staple for web pages, speaking of. And glad that the Internet has joined the conversation–as a place to both democratize and preserve knowledge, with its databases that arguably can be considered a new frontier of whatever can be interpreted, rearranged, and decomposed.

–Yifan Xia (653-02)

Tagged with: , , ,
Posted in Classification, Knowledge Structures

Mapping Lawn Use in Fort Greene Park

A map is a knowledge organization system, and its legend describes its classification scheme.

I’ve walked past this sign in Fort Greene Park many times, and I’ve seen the sections of the park fenced off to keep dogs and people off the grass. I never paid much attention to the signage before taking this Knowledge Organization course.

When I first saw the title “KO in the Wild,” I imagined a collection of posts about how used bookstores and record shops are organized, street signage, urban information design systems, subway maps and schedules, and other examples of knowledge organization in the physical world. So I thought it would be interesting to look at the maps and signage used by NYC Parks and the Fort Greene Park Conservancy to manage lawn use.

The classification system in use here is spatial and temporal, showing how different parts of the grass at Fort Greene Park are being rotated to preserve the health of the lawn. The four categories shown on the legend are off-leash, on-leash, passive, and closed for reseeding.

I think of maps as one of the foundational forms of information organization. Maps, manuscripts, books, zoology, and biological taxonomy represent some of the earliest traditions of collecting, describing, and organizing knowledge. Add mathematics, data, computers, and engineering, and you begin to arrive at something resembling information science today. The combination of geospatial data and mathematics enables climate modeling and visualization today.

The classic adage “don’t mistake the map for the territory” has become a useful metaphor for me when thinking about information literacy in different contexts. The metadata is not the resource. The abstract is not the paper. The stock market is not the economy. Our representations of things are not the things themselves.

Cartography is its own discipline, but it’s also foundational to information design. And I think this particular map is poorly designed.

It feels polished in the way marketing graphic design is polished. Almost like a print design made in Figma. Something is spiritually off about it. It’s aesthetically pleasing, but I don’t think it communicates information particularly well.

For example, the headline text on the sign reads “Upcoming Rotation.” Rotation of what? The important information, that this particular lawn right by the sign is closing on October 15, is buried in smaller text below. The sign relies on its proximity to the actual lawn that is closing, but that is not immediately clear.

The map also doesn’t appear to have a “You Are Here” marker, despite referring to “this lawn.” The legend combines several different types of classification. Off-leash and on-leash describe rules for dogs, passive describes sitting in the grass or a picnic type of activity, and closed for reseeding describes being closed totally. The map is also trying to communicate both where people can go and when those permissions will change, without clearly distinguishing the current arrangement from the upcoming one.

The legend also uses circles, which can be confused with the circles used to represent trees on the map. There is even a circle on the legend that is a very similar color. It could have used rounded squares or squares on the legend for the colors, since the corresponding colors on the map are irregular shapes anyway, and the circles are actually trees.

This is a perfect example of the difference between graphic design for marketing and branding and graphic design for information.

I regularly see people ignoring the lawn restrictions, too. It makes me wonder, if a system of knowledge organization is intended to inform behavior, and people don’t understand or follow it, is that a failure of communication design, classification, or both?

Alex Klinger (INFO 653 — 653-02)

Tagged with: , , , , , ,
Posted in Classification, Knowledge Structures

Ikea’s Shopping Experience Online vs. IRL

While shopping for my friend’s new apartment we decided to make our way down to Red Hook to check out the Ikea and get some furniture and Swedish meatballs. While there we found a cute TV stand that they didn’t have in store so I later had to go to their website to search for it again but as everything is in Swedish I realized I had to now rely on their browsing to find it. One thing that stands out to me is the way that the menu options prioritize seasonal and collaboration collections as the most prominent options. While not irrelevant, these types of products would be the most trendy and replaceable in contrast to the typical furniture staples that Ikea is known for.

https://www.ikea.com/us/en

https://www.ikea.com/us/en/rooms/living-room

Once onto the desired type of furniture you have browsing options but the most prominent options are to browse by collection name. Having a cohesive furniture collection is nice but I know for myself I definitely didn’t look at the name of the TV stand while I was there so these names were less helpful to me. It really reminded me of the way that we tend to promote and buy consumer goods in groups, like our apple ecosystem. It also emphasized on the website how much they are able to incorporate other pieces of furniture that you may not be looking for when you originally set out to purchase.

https://medium.com/illumination/the-brilliance-of-the-design-of-ikea-stores-28533b304f2c

These options also contrasted for me the experience of shopping in store. The layout of Ikea does promote exploration and investing time but it does also lay out the store more for a progression through different rooms, which is the first step of categorization on the website. Ikea is notorious for this maze like layout, which was once a problem but now feels commonplace with the constant promotion of consumption. In fact, I found that the experience of being in a store felt more exciting and almost experiential than the experience online of the many levels of promotion occurring. This change in experience from shopping online and shopping in person highlighted to me how knowledge organization can promote differing goals for the business who is doing the organizing.

– Kate Britton 653-02

Tagged with: , , ,
Posted in Classification, Knowledge Structures

The National Science Foundation’s Open Knowledge Network (NSF OKN)

I recently read about a project of the National Science Foundation, the Open Knowledge network. The network has been planned for several years and was launched on September 25, “a national open data platform connecting more than 40 knowledge graphs to power the next wave of AI discovery.” Because of my interest in knowledge organization I wanted to understand what this graph does and its purpose, beyond the platitude of powering “the next wave of AI discovery.”

“Homepage of the NSF Open Knowledge Network (okn.us). Screenshot by Sam Gutman, November 4, 2026

OKN is a network of knowledge graphs that links open knowledge graphs together in a single database . While the open knowledge graphs with which I was most familiar as a librarian linked together entity relations between works and creators and other related entities like publishers or institutions or the different manifestations of a work, the objects in the NSF’s knowledge graph are meant to the individual facts in each of its component knowledge graphs, which cover topics like health information, gene expression, environmental pollution measurements, satellite data, demographics, or criminal justice. The largest part of the graph is biomedical.

“Homepage of the NSF Open Knowledge Network (okn.us). Screenshot by Sam Gutman, November 4, 2026

The idea is that by creating this network facts will be able to translated through a crosswalk like we used to translate between Dublin core and MARC. If the different facts within the underlying data in the knowledge graphs can be connected and made searchable and readable by machines, the scientific finders involve believe it will unlock discoveries through AI processing and give humans and AI a database of known facts to query. These benefits seem still highly speculative currently.

“Homepage of the NSF Open Knowledge Network (okn.us). Screenshot by Sam Gutman, November 4, 2026

Sources:

OKN.us

https://www.nsf.gov/tip/updates/nsf-launches-open-knowledge-network-national-open-data

https://www.nsf.gov/funding/opportunities/proto-okn-building-prototype-open-knowledge-network/506169/nsf23-571

https://nsf-gov-resources.nsf.gov/2022-09/OKN%20Roadmap%20-%20Report_v03.pdf

-Sam Gutman (653-01)

Posted in Uncategorized

Classifying “Teeth”

When I first met Frankie Pittorf, I knew them as the ceramicist who “makes teeth.” Someone who was teaching and “firing” art at the same industrial arts non-profit I was grateful to do community organizing at almost a decade ago. But it wasn’t until Frankie hired me to develop their new website – an invitation I learned they not only extended because I’m a web developer, but because I’m an archivist with a thing for artist archives – did I actually get to see their full ceramic work, and understand that ceramics ultimately occupies just one small area of their greater creative practice.

Like a singular episode from a cartoon program, one piece of work by Frankie – whether it’s a graphic they’ve exported from Photoshop, or a piece of clay they’ve fired – is capable of traversing form and subject without ever leaving their visual “world.” One that not only draws upon the vocabularies of their childhood to play with gender and upbringing, but, one that posed a particular challenge when it came to deciding how to classify and organize their complete order of works on their “works” page.



Galleries expect artist websites that, customarily, organize work by exhibition, date, and/or form. But for Frankie, “form” is neither the compass they’ve used to make their art, nor the compass they use to look back at their art – their ‘world.’ For me – the web-designer who had also just entered our class’s first week on Classification and Dewey Decimal – I proposed that we honor the galleries, as well as their identity with not just one, but a few different interpretative frames for the organization of their catalogue: date and form, as well as iconography, and age. Unlike date, which organizes the catalogue by when each object was made, age, organizes Frankie’s works by the particular era of their early childhood that the object does / doesn’t speak to. Like age, iconography reaches back into Frankie’s early childhood, but by organizing works through the recurring vocabularies that make up their visual “world”: butterflies, teeth, heels, and more.

I came to this project knowing Frankie as the ceramicist who “makes teeth.” I’m leaving it knowing the teeth are memory-objects, and that stewarding them meant organizing the work around the memory-bearer and their “world.” Date and form still serve the galleries. But the project left me with a larger question, one that reaches past this single catalogue: how do different classification schemes accommodate different publics?

Steven Velazquez
INFO653-01
LIS, Archives ’28

Tagged with:
Posted in Archives, Cataloging, Classification, Knowledge Structures

Full Disclosure: The Edge of Information Design

Photograph by Jonathan Dorado. https://www.moma.org/calendar/exhibitions/5926?installation_image_index=1

Running at the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) until June 13, 2027, the exhibition, Full Disclosure: The Edge of Information, centers information and knowledge organization as a character in the featured artworks. Information design and data visualization have evolved tremendously since hieroglyphics and caveman drawings. Through mediums including but not limited to interactive software, multimedia video, inkjet prints, colored pencil drawings, and digital images, the artists here are storytellers who weave their narratives through facts, statistics, and other forms of data.

While the works are a wonderful balance of visual art and a case study, it’s intriguing to note that some of the “artists” do not necessarily label themselves as such. They include Laura Kurgan, an architect and director of Columbia University’s Center for Spatial Research, a collective of New York Times journalists led by Graphics and Multimedia Editor Larry Buchanan, and scientist Ed Hawkins.

Credit: Ed Hawkins https://www.moma.org/audio/playlist/356/4697

In 2016, Hawkins made an animated visual titled The Global Temperature Spiral. It shows the real-life impact of temperature on land and communities since 1850, when global temperature began to be properly recorded. Hawkins describes himself as a “visual learner” in his soundbite for the exhibition. The visualization is not just evidence for Hawkins and most of the artists. It is a new way of telling history that some readers couldn’t grasp from the text alone. Graphics, color, and the placement of the records can give the audience a different understanding of the world they know.

Photograph by Jonathan Dorado. https://www.moma.org/calendar/exhibitions/5926?installation_image_index=14

My favorite “artwork” is Kate Crawford and Vladan Joler’s Calculating Empires (pictured above). It explores how communication and computing technologies have evolved over time. The researchers utilize lines to demonstrate how it’s all connected. Soon, I began to think about how a device like a phone keeps extending the previous technologies into one item. It’s hard not to see the other forms of technology when you look at the work’s entire three-wall layout. The spatial placement of the text and images organizes the stats in a way that complements the audience’s reading of the work and its history.

I am a visual person myself, and this exhibition blew my mind with how data mapping could be considered art, even if some of the people featured don’t agree with that label. Whether this is art, journalism, or science, this exhibition charts a new way of absorbing knowledge and is a splendid expression of truth.

–Edward Frumkin (653-02)

Tagged with: , , , , ,
Posted in Knowledge Structures, Museums, Research Projects

Depop: Categorization and Style Lexicon

Depop is a popular clothing resale app, which uses classification and tagging to facilitate communication between buyers and sellers. Until this class, I hadn’t considered that Depop basically has all its sellers acting as cataloguers and creating metadata for what they want to get rid of in their closets. I wanted to look closer at how Depop’s Merchandising Playbook highlights the community-driven classification and terminology through the article’s recommended Listing Calendar and Style Lexicon.

I had used Depop as a buyer before I ever tried to sell anything, but when moving this past year I finally ventured into selling and became more aware of how important terminology is for the app. Depop organizes its listings much like most clothing sites divided into main categories for type of garment or object, and sub categories for color, size, brand, age, style, source, and condition of the clothing for resale.

Screenshot from The Merchandising Playbook: Listing Calendar & Style Lexicon


Perhaps Depop’s most notable cataloging feature is in descriptive language and tagging. Depop allows 5 hashtags, which the app’s Merchandising Guide notes is part of “curating an experience” for the buyer. Common descriptors include trending aesthetics or occasions, such as y2k, cottagecore, or spring break. Depop encourages sellers to update these based on what’s trending and seasonal events, such as graduation, music festivals, or holidays. Sellers often take advantage of the categorization system by purposefully classifying their listings under popular brands or aesthetics, even if they don’t quite fit or are inaccurate to the object, in order to appear in trending keyword searches.

Screenshots from The Merchandising Playbook: Listing Calendar & Style Lexicon

The app also lists on its main search page daily trending keyword searches and seasonal promotions. These visible trends make it easy for sellers to update their tagged terminology to follow, in order to make their listings visible to active app users.

So, Depop has somewhat standardized linguistic terms that act like subject headings, but also a constantly evolving vocabulary based on trends, with sellers taking on the role of cataloguers actively updating terminology and metadata.

One thing that this article doesn’t mention is that Depop sellers often don’t follow the app’s recommendation to make description as brief as possible, instead writing more personal descriptions which tell the story of the clothing to show buyers the life of the object. This shows the seller’s role as cataloguer from a very personal viewpoint. I thought this Substack post illustrates this point well:

Screenshot from Substack

In my experience, not making use of trending tags and not clearly classifying what your clothing is makes your listing invisible to buyers. I personally casually updated my listings for about two months based on what was trending, and it worked so well that I sold a few hundred dollars of clothes. After learning more about classification and metadata, Depop seemed like an example of the power of the language used in classifying and making objects visible (or invisible) within a larger system.

Sources:

Depop. (2025, September 8). The Merchandising Playbook: Listing Calendar & Style Lexicon. Depop. https://www.depop.com/blog/the-merchandising-playbook-listing-calendar-and-style-lexicon/

Chen, Viv. (2025, May 13). why depop has a distinct gen z appeal over other secondhand platforms. Substack. https://substack.com/@themolehill/note/c-116713798


–Grace Boyle, INFO 653-01

Tagged with: , , , ,
Posted in Cataloging, Classification

My gripe with Discogs

For my first blog post, I raved about a website with great organization, but for this blog post I have a bone to pick. I have been using the website Discogs to organize my record and CD library for years. In theory, the concept of Discogs is great, and it does generally help me keep track of each album I own, but its organization system is awful.

Discogs is a website for cataloging and organizing music collections. It allows users to search a vast music database, explore artists, find hyper-specific releases (i.e., a vinyl with only 5 existing copies in the world), buy and sell albums, rate and review albums, and create a digital collection of their personal music library. In theory, it should be a very helpful, fun tool for organizing a music collection, but I’ve found some of its features and organization limiting and confusing. My two main gripes are their inconsistent genre labeling and their restrictive collection organization.

My first issue is how Discogs categorizes albums by genre. When I added all my music to my account, I thought it would make it easy to find music that fit a specific style, like jazz or rock, or other common genres. However, its genre classifications are somewhat unreliable. In my library, the soul genre contains Talking Heads and Beatles albums, an album that is literally just orchestra music is listed under pop, the Rolling Stones fall under classical music, and apparently Bob Marley and Liza Minnelli are considered country artists. Music genres are fluid and albums don’t always fall easily into them, but many of these classifications just feel outright wrong.

When I saw how poor Discogs’ genre classification was, I thought I’d just make my own genre folders. This is where my second gripe comes in. On Discogs, you are able to create custom folders to sort albums into, which seems like a helpful feature until you realize each album can only be assigned to one folder. This presents an issue when an album could genuinely fall into multiple categories. If you create a jazz folder and add an album there, but it also could easily fall into blues, now you have to decide which feels more appropriate. Genres overlap all the time and artists often experiment with different musical styles within one album. If I decide to organize my collection by genre, then I can’t have self-made categories like favorites, or good albums for a dinner party. The custom folders present a huge limitation for a website that is specifically designed for cataloging and organizing music.

Both of these issues might be minor, and not something every Discogs user struggles with, but I think they reflect some big organizational issues. For such a large database with so much metadata, Discogs is shockingly disorganized. Music is inherently layered, and that should be reflected in their organizational system. I think the limitations presented on Discogs only make the information on there harder to retrieve and organize, making it an overall less effective tool. They could really benefit from giving users more flexibility in how they organize their library, as well as more consistent genre classification. There is so much potential for Discogs as a music organization tool, but it fails in quite a few ways. A website designed for organizing personal music collections needs to give up some control and allow users to organize in a way that makes sense to them.

Meaghan Hackett – 653-01

Posted in Cataloging, Classification

The Purple Store

The Purple Store is an online store that sells a wide variety of items (from $3 stickers to $8,000 couches), all of which are purple. I came across this site by accident many years ago, and while I didn’t end up purchasing anything, the concept of the site stuck with me. Our class discussions of classification and categorization reminded me of the store, so I decided to revisit it.

The site assures shoppers that anything they purchase on the site will be undeniably purple – they “find the true color items so you can trust it won’t arrive pink or blue.” Categorizing can be subjective and arbitrary, and the site’s claim made me wonder how they handle ambiguous cases, and whether shoppers ever disagree about whether an item is truly purple. The store’s FAQ section addresses this question, noting “if you receive a product that is supposed to be purple and it turns out to be so Lilac Smoke that it’s grey, so Lavender that it’s blue, or so Mauve that it’s pink, please let us know. We’re committed to connecting you with purple products, not close approximations.” The wording here is striking – the notion that an item can be “so” much a subcategory of purple that it leaves the parent category of “purple” altogether.

The site features an elaborate structure of categories organizing the store’s inventory. There is a toolbar on the left side of the page summarizing the store’s main categories (26 categories organized alphabetically, and 5 categories listed separately at the top), and links to a page where the categories and subcategories are laid out clearly. The categories are listed in alphabetical order, with each subcategory listed in slightly smaller writing under the parent category. The list includes brief descriptions of what can be found in each category.

The logic to the way this list is organized is a bit inconsistent — 6 of the categories start with the word “purple”, which seems redundant given the purpose of the site. The assignment of items to each category is sometimes surprising. The “Office” category includes items that could be used for quite a wide range of jobs – in addition to the items I expected (like pens and folders), the page includes a hard hat, incense, craft paint, and an octopus toy. Items can be listed in multiple categories, so there is a lot of cross-listing of items.

Given that each item can be listed in numerous categories, some of the exclusions of items from certain categories and subcategories are puzzling. This is especially true in the division of items within the gendered “Clothes” subcategories. The “Owner of the World’s Cutest Dog Purple Socks” are listed only in the “Men” section, while the “F***ing Hustle Purple Socks” are listed only in the “Women” section, even though both items are described as unisex. After further investigation, I noticed that certain item pages include tags that link to pages where you can browse subcategories that are inaccessible from the main “categories” page. The socks I had found earlier were each tagged with the subcategory “Purple Socks and Hosiery” and the sub-sub-categories “Women’s Socks” and “Men’s Socks”. There doesn’t appear to be a location on the site where you can view all of the available tags – you can only access them by clicking on individual items that fall within these categories. After exploring the site I found a variety of tags, including categorizations based on material (“Purple Leather”, “Purple Faux Fur”, “Purple Velvet”) and qualities (“Shiny Purple!”, “Green Purple” – eco-friendly purple items).

The Purple Store also links to the Internet Archive’s record of how their site has changed over time — it’s interesting to see how the store’s classification system has gotten more complex over the years.

References:

The Purple Store—Everything We Sell is Purple. (n.d.). Retrieved November 3, 2026, from https://www.thepurplestore.com/

Anna Miller INFO 653-01

Tagged with: , , ,
Posted in Classification

Letterboxd – social cataloging for movies

I want to highlight Letterboxd, the popular online social cataloging service for movies. Founded in 2011, its membership exploded during the pandemic and it has only grown in popularity since then. Its popularity has to be partly attributed to the ease of design and the community-focused nature of the service. As of July 2022, over 1 billion films have been logged on Letterboxd. You can use the platform to log and look through what you’ve watched, save films to watch later, rate and review movies, and generate lists by category.

Not only are there seemingly endless movie lists organized to suit any taste or need and generated both by Letterboxd and by users, but the platform also encourages user engagement by highlighting other users’ activities.

You can even follow users whose tastes, lists or reviews interest you.

Letterboxd doesn’t just catalog movies, it also catalogs users:

Letterboxd has become so popular, that several celebrities use it, like Charli xcx, Carrie Coon, Mike Flanagan, Anne Hathaway, Jack Harlow, and Kid Cudi to name a few. It’s also used by professional film critics like David Sims of The Atlantic. I’ve included his profile below:

You can see the wide variety of information provided, as well as how much the user is able to catalog and track: his favorite movies and recent watches; recent reviews and lists; dates of recent movies watched; as well as the total number of films watched, watched this year, number of lists, number of followers and following. So much information, all so easily accessible!

I enjoy Sims’ writing in The Atlantic, but his one-sentence reviews on Letterboxd might be even better:

And let’s not forget his creative use of the list feature:

The ease of use, clean design, sense of accomplishment gained and joy of perusal and comparison make Letterboxd one of the best and most successful social cataloging platforms online.

  • Taylor Haunschild, INFO-653-01

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letterboxd

https://letterboxd.com

Tagged with: , ,
Posted in Cataloging, Classification

by Hugh McLeod

Follow INFO 653 Knowledge Organization on WordPress.com
Pratt Institute School of Information